The thoughts of a web 2.0 research fellow on all things in the technological sphere that capture his interest.

Tuesday 9 October 2007

Is Manchester the second city or just a big footballing city?

Hitwise has access to loads of data that I would love to get my hands on, the sort of data that would keep me busy for the rest of my academic life. It is therefore probably pure jealousy that makes me complain about some of the ways it utilises its data. Its latest post addresses the question: Which is the UK's second city? As well as showing the traffic to the cities' respective tourist information sites, it also shows that Manchester is searched for more often than Birmingham.

Unfortunately it fails to mention one particularly word. Football. Manchester United are the current premiership champions, whilst Manchester City ride high in the table under the previous England manager Sven Goran Eriksson. In comparison Birmingham City bob between the premiership and the championship and Aston Villa doesn't even have Birmingham in their title!

Does football make much of a difference? Well Google trends would seem to suggest that it can. Liverpool can be seen to have shot past Manchester on the back of its footballing glories (and failures), whilst Arsenal have have captured as many hits as Manchester on occassion without the additional 'city' searches.



I appreciate that the purpose of these articles is to show the sort of data Hitwise can provide your company with, but these sort of analyses are just a bit annoying...but as I say, its probably just jealousy.

Labels: , ,

posted by David at

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi David,

Thanks for reading the blog - I'm afraid I can't help you with the jealousy, but maybe I can take away a bit of the frustration!

We have a very useful tool called Search Term Suggestions that lists the total number of searche terms containing a word. There were 46,000 search terms containing the word 'manchester' last week compared to 28,000 containing 'Birmingham'. As for the football aspect, 'Manchester United' was the second most popular term containing 'Manchester', and accounted 3.6% of all 'Manchester' searches.

Obviosuly there are also variations on 'Manchester United' too - there were almost 3,000 search terms containing 'Manchester United'. So, we can say that there were 43,000 search terms containing 'Manchester' EXCLUDING all searches containing 'Manchester United', compared to 28,000 for Birmingham. And that is before I take out football related terms for Birmingham and those relating to the other Birmingham in the US, which probably gets quite a few searches from the UK considering its historical links with civil rights movement.

I hope that clears things up a bit! We also did some analysis of Manchester United's popularity vs. Liverpool at the start of the season here: http://www.hitwise.co.uk/press-center/hitwiseHS2004/sports.php

Keep your eyes peeled for more football analysis during the upcoming international break, especially if Arsenal gain market share...

Thanks, Robin

9 October 2007 at 15:10

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oh - one other thing. If you really are interested in getting your hands on our data, drop me a line and we may be able to sort something out. We're always interested in working with the academic community.

Thanks, Robin

9 October 2007 at 15:15

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home